Nearly all of us who enter the medical field do so with the main intention of caring for others. We often also have secondary motivations—a love for science, an innate curiosity about how our bodies work, a small degree of masochism—but at our core, many of us just want to help people. That desire to care is not limited to people like ourselves; we care for all, regardless of race, religion, or ideology.
This is most obvious in emergency situations when instincts take over. When a patient arrives in critical condition, it doesn’t matter if they’re a sweet old grandma or domestic abuser with swastikas tattooed down their chest; we will do our best to save their lives all the same. But are there ever situations in which a medical professional should recuse themselves from care of a patient?
There are obvious situations in which the patient is a family member or you are not medically qualified to help the patient—no one would expect your significant other to be your patient or for a dermatologist to fix a fractured femur. In these cases, you pass on care to someone else. This is seen as completely acceptable and in line with the modern Hippocratic Oath: “I will not be ashamed to say ‘I know not,’ nor will I fail to call in my colleagues when the skills of another are needed for a patient’s recovery.”
Now consider non-life-threatening situations in which the patient’s ideology might impact your ability to care for them based on your own views. For example, take caring for the sweet old grandma and the domestic abuser again. This time, instead of a critical care situation, they are both coming in for consultations for a quality of life procedure, such as a knee replacement or cosmetic surgery. Do you believe that your ability to care for these patients will be completely uncompromised? And if you believe you have any sort of bias towards this patient, do you have an ethical obligation to pass care of that patient onto another physician who doesn’t? Though this may be within your area of expertise, if you are not able to utilize your skills on the basis of your ethics, does this still fall under the Hippocratic Oath and needing to “call in [your] colleagues when the skills of another are needed for a patient’s recovery”?
And if this is the case, where do you draw the line? Or are you allowed to recuse yourself from care of people based on their sexual orientation or is it right to not prescribe contraceptives if it goes against your own personal ideologies? Historically, courts have sided with medical professionals in these situations where they have been fired or reprimanded when they refused to provide care if it violates their principals [1].
Or is it simply our duty, as health care professionals, to look past any of our own beliefs regardless of which end of the spectrum they fall on—to respect patient autonomy and provide them with the best possible care in both life-threatening and routine situations? Is this not something we agreed to, setting aside our personal principles in service to our patients, when we first donned the white coat?
[1] Erdely, S., 2020. Doctors’ Beliefs Can Hinder Patient Care. [online] msnbc.com. Available at: http://www.nbcnews.com/id/19190916/ns/health-womens_health/t/doctors-beliefs-can-hinder-patient-care/ [Accessed 11 July 2020]
BLURBS FOR EMAIL/SOCIAL MEDIA
(science) Shivraj Grewal visualizes racial and ethnic disparities in COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations in Maricopa County.
(art) Charlotte Archuleta explores the need for creative pursuit and the scientific evidence behind engagement with the arts and anxiety reduction.
(op-ed) Pareena Kaur shares her experience continuing to provide patient care and further her medical education through a telemedicine rotation
(business) Aaron Tran unearths the vast implications of COVID-19 on the economy and its impact on the healthcare sector
(interprofessional) Jessica Pirkle-Callan speaks with Megan Senftleben, BSN, Director of Crisis Services at Community Bridges Inc.
(op-ed) Kristina Yancey shares the personal experience of Eddie Case, an early survivor of COVID-19
(interprofessional) Mohammad Khan speaks with physical therapist Valeria Ngai about her work with children and the use of horses as a therapy modality.
(culture) Mohammad Khan discusses the development and implementation of a new PAL elective, “Cafecitos en La Casa” with PAL block director Dr. Sue Kim
(culture) Three medical students teamed up to make medical Spanish more central to the curriculum at UACOM - Phoenix. Read the experiences of Estefania Lopez, Alexandria Dagget, and Abigail Rocio as they talk with The Differential’s Mohammad Khan.
(ethics) When should physicians excuse themselves from providing care based on personal beliefs? Arjun Johal considers the ethical implications of this question.